Maggie Gyllenhaal

[murkrow]

Ruined "Dark Knight".

1. she's not attractive enough to match the script.
2. she's not a strong enough actor.

 

[Anti-socialite]

I did think it was odd that they chose Maggie (especially to play opposite Christien Bale ) but I am a fan of hers. Loved her in Secretary and Stranger Than Fiction.

 

[PreAlgebra]

I totally disagree. I think that it was a great role for her because she is not a typical actress for that role and she pulled it off well. I think that she is very gorgeous and a good actress. Have you seen Stranger Than Fiction? She is amazingly hot in that.

 

[Radioactive_Springtime]

maybe they should have used her brother and just called it brokebatman...i hate myself for that one.

 

[PreAlgebra]

Oh, thats a good one^ I would hate myself too for it.

 

[Anti-socialite]

I totally disagree. I think that it was a great role for her because she is not a typical actress for that role and she pulled it off well. I think that she is very gorgeous and a good actress. Have you seen Stranger Than Fiction? She is amazingly hot in that.

I haven't seen the movie yet but I'm sure she performed fantastically (again, I am a fan) but she just seems odd for that type of flick. Sometimes the leading man matters, too. But Christien Bale is an enigma so maybe he doesn't count.

 

[Anti-socialite]

Ruined "Dark Knight".

1. she's not attractive enough to match the script.
2. she's not a strong enough actor.

Oh wait! I just realized that you said she ruined the movie. Haven't seen it but I doubt that.

 

[Decaf]

I thought she brought a hell of a lot more chutzpah to the role than Katie "Pretty Face" Holmes. I couldn't believe Katie would stand up to that kind of intense pressure, but I could believe that of Maggie. She wasn't perfect, but she was better.

 

[fullerene]

how the hell did the supporting actress ruin the dark knight for you? Heath Ledger could have filmed that movie with muppets and it would have been half decent.

edit: oops, second sentence didn't quite make sense.

 

[Radioactive_Springtime]

how the hell did the supporting actress ruin the dark knight for you? Heath Ledger that movie with muppets and it would have been half decent.

Ledger's joker is pretty much the best there will ever be. Ever.

 

[Anti-socialite]

I thought she brought a hell of a lot more chutzpah to the role than Katie "Pretty Face" Holmes. I couldn't believe Katie would stand up to that kind of intense pressure, but I could believe that of Maggie. She wasn't perfect, but she was better.

You can't compare Maggie Gyllenhaal and Katie Holmes. F***ing Katie Holmes?! COME ON!!