Oh, you certainly have your points.
It treat it (Scifi), though loving it, not as religion, or as main purpose of my life, but as a fun to think about and it has (good scifi) some interesting things to say about our reality, our society(ies). But what these people are doing (for an example of this overscrutinising
here and look into a random thread), i don't know, i find it really stupid. You know, some people may say that i have little 'real life' as well, as in little 'social life', and i enjoy occupying myself with imagination (like in Scifi, Fantasy or whatnot), but even though i am nowhere near their level of involvement. I think they have way too much time on their hands. For me there are so many interesting things to do, to learn, that i wouldn'T waste so much time going so deep into one thing (like arguing wether or not whatever little detail is this or that way, see my example of hallucination and elevator).
But i don't think it is limited to Scifi. This happens with most things people tend to get fans of (fans as in fanatics, really). Perhaps people need some thing to involve themselves so much with, and some choose some TV show for it?
I see no problem with the discussion getting into a more serious one, but that's up to you (or others who wanna join or end this)
Ogion